MacDougall's: reference sales
Results of the June MacDougall's, where D offered its forecast somewhat surprised. On the fact the prices were often higher than even the boldest assumptions D
Results of the June MacDougall's, which suggested that its forecast D 1 , somewhat surprised. On the fact the prices were often higher than even the boldest assumptions D. Case that is made when drafting the price forecast, the projected figures in some way affect the status of the auction house, where the growth is happening for many years. Observed that when the bids are for auctions «first-line» (primarily at Sotheby's and Christie's), then prices should be typed above - often higher than any reasonable and justifiable investment values. The reasons: a well-known playground, going to a lot of bidders, higher competition, the purchase are often of the image. Yes There is good reason to shop at art boutiques? In contrast, bidding at auctions «second-line» in projections take into account a subjective discount. Reasoning about this: at Sotheby's it would have to pay 100 and something there, but it is not Sotheby's, and therefore more likely to be 90.
Alexander Kharitonov. Secret Heavenly. Oil on canvas. 30 x 42. Estimeyt: 15-20 thousand pounds. Forecast D: 17 thousand pounds. Sale price: 51,4 thousand pounds MacDougall's. 15.06.07. Lot number 253
At this time-tested logic did not work. Trades MacDougall's post-war art in the strings passed without any significant discount - that is completely on sotbisovskim prices. Perhaps the reason has become a good selection of things on the background of the ongoing «bezrybya» on Russian theme in the world's auction catalogs. Especially things that fairly strong Sixties young English auction offers are not the first time, at that time to draw the attention of collectors interested in this topic, as well as investors.
As usual, most notoriously into the purchase price into a sensation. Auction on 15 June is likely to be associated with the fact that it is sold «Five persons» Tselkova for 223,1 thousand pounds - nearly half a million dollars. Work is good, colorful, decorative. But in order to explain such a price would have to first understand why the very similar as for the technical parameters, and on the story thing «Five masks» was sold at Sotheby's «only» of 132 thousand pounds - almost twice cheaper. For «Five persons» good in 1980 was appointed as prohibitively high estimeyt 170-220 thousand pounds. It is from this perspective, D, made quite confidently forecast «Not sold». And wrong. However, such an attachment, if the goal set is the investment should be designed for relatively long payback period. The picture will still cost so much, but only a couple-three years. Incidentally, such a success Tselkova may additionally explained by the fact that his work had already entered the exposition clip art in the postwar GTG at Krymsky Val.
VLADIMIR ВЕЙСБЕРГ. The composition of the sculptures. 1979. Oil on canvas. 51 x 51. Estimeyt: 65-90 thousand pounds. Forecast D: 75 thousand pounds. Total trades: «Do not sold». MacDougall's. 15.06.07. Lot number 224
Strange Sensation number two - Alexander Kharitonov. Trading for a small picture «Secret Heavenly» estimeytom with 15-20 thousand pounds was completed at around 51.4 thousand pounds (nearly 102 thousand dollars). If there is no doubt about the authenticity, according to D, a good price for such a thing would have been 17 thousand pounds, not 50. In this opinion, we remain. Another point is that in terms of the authenticity of this specific D «Secrets of the celestial» is strong doubts. So it remains to repeat that result in all countries. In general, the religious symbolism Kharitonova quite a few fans among the collectors, and prices are increasing rapidly, which often is a breeding ground for the emergence of different «strangenesses».
What's surprising work «metaphysical» Krasnopevtseva Dmitry and Vladimir Вейсберга - long-standing favorite of collectors - this time gave vivid examples of discrepancies D projections with actual performance. And this time we will be overestimated. Women's suitcase size canvas Krasnopevtseva «Still life with bottles» 1984 at estimeyte 50-70 thousand pounds had been sold for nearly 90 thousand pounds (in thousands of U.S. $ 178.1). Editorial score was higher - 110 thousand pounds. But it is not happening. Maybe decoration is not enough, maybe the mood. In general, observed that in recent months related to Krasnopevtsevu became calmer. Gone is promiscuity and vanity, which emerged after the famous millionth sale at Sotheby's (a record «Krasnopevtsev», if you remember, was a particularly warm bright colors). That is, interest in art continues to be significant, the importance of the artist had not been revised, but to mark 200 thousand dollars a line of buyers no longer is organized. The phenomenon is likely temporary. Sometimes an excess of attention to the work of an artist is replaced by fatigue, but then eliminated random buyers enthusiastic flow of fashionable shopping, and remain objective connoisseurs.
much more trouble occurred with canvas Vladimir Вейсберга «Composition with sculptures» 1979. D indicated that the main drawback specific work - is its size (51 cm on the side of the square), and the artist liked to keep large air fields. Upper estimeyt also seemed velikovat. In short, the composition is not sold. This thing, of course, can not be classified as masterpieces, but, according to D, the auction value of such a work of art-recognized market for the artist could easily be 75 thousand pounds. Writing is «do not sell» adversely affect the reputation and history of things. Now would be a better song Вейсберга «otvisetsya» - must be months or years to try again sell it to public auction.
pickup done at MacDougall's fans creativity lianozovtsa Vladimir Nemukhin and sretentsa Vladimir Yankylevsky. Very decorative nemuhinsky meter canvas «Soir», 1978, with estimeyte 40-60 thousand pounds had been sold for thousands of pounds 72.66. And, according to D, even level of 90 thousand pounds for such a thing was entirely justified. So the buyer «Soir» to be congratulated. As the new owner of Graphic kollazhnogo «Self» Vladimir Yankylevsky. An effective and recognizable composition was bought on the cheap - for 5,3 thousand pounds, with forecasts for the D 7 thousand pounds. Portfolio Yankylevsky still strongly underestimated, but now even the paper 5.3 thousand pounds - a good price. For a company with the rest of you can rejoice and for the buyer «smoker» Oleg Tselkova 1994. A small and very interior work is ideally suited to the role of «first tselkova» in the family. What contributes to the price - 15.9 thousand pounds, as predicted D. The perception of this work does not require high training audience. No call and emotional tension. A person with a pipe smoking is not even nervous. But the fact that fans of the art Tselkova is a drawback for the novice collector - just find.
VLADIMIR Nemukhin. Still Life with «Russkaya Mysl». 1992. Paper, see v. 80 x 60. Collection A. Glezera. Estimeyt: 8-12 thousand pounds. Forecast D: 12 thousand pounds. Sale price: 15,9 thousand pounds. MacDougall's. 15.06.07. Lot number 227
Forecast for the two works exhibited Vechtomova D Nicholas was forced to do if not random, in conditions of high uncertainty. On a whim. For work recently gone from a life lianozovtsa it was then that the reference of auction sales, but even the prevailing market price benchmarks gallery. In other words, the professional members of the art market, until recently, could only rely on their intuition to determine how much should it cost Vechtomova work. Same sense dictates that prices will move in the same price range that nemuhinskie. Falls, but not immediately. The June auction of MacDougall's, strangely enough, waited as the first demonstration bidding for works Vechtomova. Besides, with things lucky - both recognizable characteristic, valuable. According to one - painting and graphics. As a result, oil on canvas «Black Sun» 1990, was sold for thousands of 28.27 pounds (55 thousand dollars). Forecast D was quite close - 25 thousand pounds, to 5 thousand more than the most daring estimeyt. Similar to a plot, but in a different color graphics «protection» of 1972, with estimeyte 4-6 thousand pounds had also been sold in almost exactly on the predicted D. We expect 15 thousand pounds, and the facts were 14.13 thousand pounds. According to D, the price movement of labor Vechtomova is in the process of beginning «raskachki». Collectors and investors are forced to ostorozhnichat, but for works of this artist's chance of price «breakthrough» much higher than that of his more famous works of art-market colleagues Lianozovsky group.
In terms of complexity comparable to the uncertainty of D had to predict the outcome of tendering for the work of «panic realist» Peter Belenkov «bathing man» (1987). To this end, the artist is still never the criteria for assessing creativity - the prices are appointed intuitively. From the artistic point of view of work is not outstanding. D at one time encouraged investors to look better to the more impressive things with the black swirl. In our opinion, they have a high investment potential. For the same specific meter song D gave a forecast 12 thousand pounds. Guess, but do not guess. Things eventually was sold for 8, 99 thousand pounds.
Vladimir Yankilevsky. Self-portrait. 1995. Paper, see t. 58,5 x 79. Estimeyt: 4-6 thousand pounds. Forecast D: 7 thousand pounds. Sale price: 5,3 thousand pounds. MacDougall's. 15.06.07. Lot number 312
leader list «haylaytov» version D - Abstraction «The Ship» (1969) work Yevgenia Rukhin - experts appointed estimeyt 60 thousand pounds. D was not an example of courage - 80 thousand pounds. The projections we have recognized that the 80 thousand pounds (160 thousand dollars) - the price at the time unlikely high. But I did not, arguing that the truly remarkable thing. It turned out, and this estimate was conservative. Trading Results for «Boat» - 109,2 thousand pounds (216.2 thousand U.S. dollars). Perhaps, from this point on, you can take that Rukhin «shot». Even three years ago, the usual price for abstractions Petersburg beaver were 15-20 thousand dollars. Then we talked about that this is not normal, and works by the artist greatly underestimated. Then, a year ago, they began to pay 30-60 thousand dollars, and we keep talking about the high investment potential. Now, 216 thousand dollars. Well, not surprisingly, now it is quite normal for a range of high quality items of Representatives «another art».
In general, at an auction June 15, was found a few prices of personal records. One of the most remarkable results - 400 thousand pounds for two-sided canvas Maria Vasilyeva (1884-1957). Jobs representatives «Paris School» - kubisticheskie «Man» on the one hand and the «woman», on the other - was appreciated in the wake growth of interest in terms of the Montparnasse painters Soutine, Modigliani, etc. Earlier work Matisse students were able to approach the mark in the 200 thousand dollars, but to millions of dollars they never approached. In general, it is able to lift An effective selling for tens of per cent of the price level for the work of artist.
pride in the prognosis of D - the result of bidding for a series of four canvases «Seasons» Dmitry Stelletskogo brush. Evaluation of the auction house was 100-150 thousand pounds. D found it too conservative and has more than doubled the forecast ceiling estimeyta. Triggering condition of this development D indicated high decorative properties canvases - bright saturated palette, which is not always accompanied creativity notable representative of «World of Art». And so it happened. Forecast - 300 thousand pounds. On the fact - 284 thousand pounds.
Record to work Stelletskogo.
1 See.: Art news /prepare. Bogdanov //Direktor-Info. 2007. 11. S. 32-39. Return
Source:
Permanent link to:
https://artinvestment.ru/en/news/artnews/20070616_Macdoug.html
https://artinvestment.ru/news/artnews/20070616_Macdoug.html
© artinvestment.ru, 2024
Attention! All materials of the site and database of auction results ARTinvestment.RU, including illustrated reference information about the works sold at auctions, are intended for use exclusively for informational, scientific, educational and cultural purposes in accordance with Art. 1274 of the Civil Code. Use for commercial purposes or in violation of the rules established by the Civil Code of the Russian Federation is not allowed. ARTinvestment.RU is not responsible for the content of materials submitted by third parties. In case of violation of the rights of third parties, the site administration reserves the right to remove them from the site and from the database on the basis of an application from an authorized body.
